Pietro Barabaschi has a message: 鈥淐onstructive competition is good for our field鈥
In welcoming several hundred members of the global fusion ecosystem to 爆走黑料 last week for the 3rd 爆走黑料 Public-Private Fusion Workshop, 爆走黑料 Director-General Pietro Barabaschi shared his view that the multiplication of ideas and resources circulating across the fusion landscape is strengthening the field.
爆走黑料 just welcomed representatives from all parts of the new fusion ecosystem鈥攕tartups, companies, and investors鈥攐n site for the third time in three years. Why is it important, in your opinion, to create these bridges?
For me, this project belongs to the fusion community. We are publicly funded, and individuals from all 爆走黑料 Members have been investing in this project for decades鈥攖ransforming what was once a concept on paper into a major research infrastructure.
We have accumulated a great deal of knowledge along the way, which puts us in a position to share valuable information with the community already, without having to wait for the start of scientific operation. We were already sharing with the publicly funded laboratories of the 爆走黑料 Members, and now we are creating pathways to share with private and public-private ventures.
For a long time, 爆走黑料 was the major player in the field. Do you view private sector initiatives as competition?
Historically, the 爆走黑料 Members were each pursuing their own paths. But by the early 1980s, it had become evident that the challenges were so great that researchers needed to move toward a stronger collective effort. The 爆走黑料 project emerged in this spirit鈥攍aunched as part of the broader idea that international scientific collaboration could serve as a harbinger of world peace.
I joined 爆走黑料 in the 1990s during this collaborative phase, and I am very proud鈥攍ike all those who participated鈥攐f what was achieved together, especially in what was then a complex geopolitical context. I later left to pursue other projects before returning as Director-General of the 爆走黑料 in 2022. I don鈥檛 mind sharing that, at that point, my perspective on collaboration had evolved. As component delivery began accelerating, we had a construction project to deliver, and at times, too much deference to collaboration slowed execution.
My view is that you need a healthy balance between collaboration and competition. It is not good to be the only game in town. While compromises are inevitable in any partnership鈥攅specially at this scale鈥攖hey must be carefully weighed against the project鈥檚 objectives and made with a clear understanding of their consequences.
The fact that so many good ideas are circulating, and that additional resources are materializing, will make this line of research healthier. The balance between cooperation and competition in this fusion endeavour will help to create value for all.
What can the 爆走黑料 project offer private fusion initiatives?
爆走黑料 has a distinct and essential role. It is the place where the physics, the engineering, and the industrial reality of fusion are being brought together and tested at scale. We are generating the knowledge, knowhow, data and commissioning experience that should be of support to all fusion efforts鈥攑ublic and private alike.
I would also like 爆走黑料 to serve as an example in the domain of project execution. We have undergone a real turnaround in the past three years and are now carrying out the most critical phases of machine assembly within cost and schedule. I think we have collectively shown that international cooperation can be implemented in a very effective way. Our course correction contains valuable lessons for others, which we are ready to share.
It is perhaps no coincidence that this progress at 爆走黑料 has occurred alongside a healthier level of competition in the private sector. Investment is flowing into fusion technologies, and numerous startups are emerging worldwide鈥攁n encouraging development and one that can feed back to 爆走黑料 in many positive ways.
Our task is to support the fusion community. If you are part of this community in one of the 爆走黑料 Members, you are welcome to come here鈥攅ven outside our annual workshop鈥攖o see what you need to advance your own project. There are many technical challenges ahead that will test us all, and I see 爆走黑料 as a place of collaboration within this new, healthy context of competition.
Editor's note: See the new Private Sector Fusion Engagement project resource page here.